Tim Casteel

Thoughts on Leadership and College Ministry

Eval

Resources to Use for December Planning

By

As we head into the final weeks of the fall semester in college ministry, it’s a great time to step back and evaluate.

I wanted to share a few resources that have been helpful for our team as we seek to figure out if we have set our ladder against the right wall; to figure out what we should be focused on in the spring, and beyond.

We send out two evals to our team (just sent it out last night) to do on their own so we don’t have to take time during staff meeting to eval (we will compile all the evals and just read them together as a team). We do 2 evals since we have several AIA staff on our team and most ministry-strategy-stuff doesn’t relate to them. Here’s what I sent my team:
  • “The All Staff eval is SUPER short. It’ll take you 5-7 minutes.
  • The Cru Team Eval (AIA doesn’t need to do) will take a little longer – maybe 30 minutes”
Aside from those surveys that we send to our staff, a couple other helpful resources to help you evaluate your ministry:
  • We ask each of our staff to do the first part of this eval with each person they disciple: Evaluating the Quality of Your Discipleship (I believe this was developed by Roger Hershey). The second half of the Discipleship eval is good for each staff to do as they think through everyone they are discipling:  Which of your disciples is presently multiplying? And of those who are not multiplying, what are the barriers?
  • Cru Press Green (via Collegiate Collective!) has a great set of Eval questions
Here’s the agenda for our three days of December planning. Hopefully you can take some of this to use in your planning.

 

Day 1 of Planning:

Goal of week – To chart our course for the near future.  To set our direction.  And to be totally prepared to get started when we get back on day before classes start — Mon, Jan. 18
We spend the semester furiously climbing a ladder
Planning is a time to stop climbing and assess whether our ladder is leaning against the right wall, to re-evaluate where we’ve been and whether we are headed in the right direction
“The organizations that matter are busy being run by people who figure out what to do next” — Seth Godin
Some of what we will accomplish this week:
  • The first 6 weeks of Spring mapped out (and broadstrokes for whole Spring)
  • A thorough plan for each Critical Path Step for the spring
  • Winter Conference details nailed down (campus times, etc)
  • Leadership Retreat at beginning of year planned out
  • Our evangelistic strategy mapped out for Spring
  • Connecting with one another
Today= Where we are headed and where we are (Current Reality)
Go thru compiled evals 
In light of those evals, what should discuss/figure out this week:
BREAK
Current Reality (reality is our friend)
Numbers in Bible studies
how many freshmen involved
How are we on our goals for this year?
Count # of students who have shared their faith
5 year Dream
We just diagnosed where we are
Where are we going?
Where do you want to go?
What would it look like to have faith and trust the Lord for more?  Let’s go for it!  Where are we going? Have we lost vision for reaching the whole campus?  Reaching all of the pockets?
Ministry vs Movement

A ministry can mean you’re doing great stuff – connecting the lost to Jesus and seeing lives change.But if we stop there, we just have a ministryA ministry is content with haphazard, dead end, life change.Dead end in that students rarely multiply their lives.Haphazard in that we’re content with seeing random students experience life change but they never are called to work together to a greater purpose, a mission, a cohesive vision for something bigger than themselvesA movement is going somewhere together through multiplicationSpecifically – a ministry becomes a movement when people begin to multiply their lives into others AND they are moving somewhere togetherNot just scattershot. But multiplication in a particular direction. Specifically for us, our vision is that everyone on campus would know someone who passionately follows Christ. So we want students multiplying their lives until everyone on campus hears about Christ from a friend.

Read 12 year plan: link
Where are we at on the 12 year plan?

Brainstorm: Where do we want to be by 2020 [for frame of reference, our previous 5 year plan)?

DEVO – Jesus is better than ministry success or lack of success!
Devo — the gospel – succeed or fail – we have Jesus – our identity in him
Luke 10:17-20
We need to remember that our identity is in Christ — not in ministry success/failure
Psalm 4:7-8
You have put more joy in my heart
than they have when their grain and wine abound.
In peace I will both lie down and sleep;
for you alone, O Lord, make me dwell in safety.CH Mackintosh in his commentary on Exodus:
“The one who will present Christ to others must be occupied with Christ for himself. Happy is the one who ministers in this way, whatever be the success or reception of his ministry. For should his ministry fail to attract attention, to command influence or to produce apparent results, he has his sweet retreat and his unfailing portion in Christ of which nothing can deprive him. Whereas the person who is merely feeding upon the fruits of his ministry, who delight in the gratification which it affords or the attention & interest which it commands, is like a mere pipe conveying water to others while retaining only rust for himself. This is a most deplorable condition to be in, and yet it’s the actual condition of every servant who is more occupied with his work and its results than with the Master and His glory.”

No matter how the fall went — fail or succeed, I have Christ.

Paul David Tripp has said, “It is very tempting to try to get your identity from your ministry success.” And the opposite is true as well — it’s very tempting to let ministry “failure” define you and shape your trust in God.I’ll let Tripp continue to preach (from his excellent book Dangerous Calling).

He identifies several things that pastors uniquely struggle with. #1? I LET MINISTRY DEFINE MY IDENTITY.

“Because you have a secure identity as a child of God, you don’t need to seek identity from the success of your ministry. You can do this because your standing with God is not based on your performance but on the perfect obedience of Christ. You need to preach these truths to yourself daily, because in ministry you either seek to get identity from your ministry or stand firm and secure in the identity you have been given in Christ.”

“Human beings are always assigning to themselves some kind of identity. There are only two places to look. Either you will be getting your identity vertically, from who you are in Christ, or you will be shopping for it horizontally in the situations, experiences, and relationships of your daily life. This is true of everyone, but I am convinced that getting one’s identity horizontally is a particular temptation for those in ministry.”
“The success of a ministry is always more a picture of who God is than a statement about who the people are that he is using for his purpose.”

 

Day 2 of Planning:

Prayer – For the Day, Wisdom, Pray for Winter Conference
5 Year Dream follow up convo
Break
Good springs lead to good falls
Ask-> What would make a good fall (especially in terms of student leadership)?
When it comes to the fall, it’s all about manpower. If it’s just your staff team and 4 student leaders pursuing freshmen, you have a long road ahead of you. But if you line up 60 students in the spring who will focus on reaching freshmen, the fall will be good.
So the spring is the time to get your “reaching-freshmen-team” together. And to build consensus that we MUST reach freshmen.
And all this happens largely by raising up as many Community Group Leaders as possible.
So everything you do in the spring should contribute to assembling this team of leaders (tomorrow I’ll share some of the changes we made to be more focused on this with our spring).
  • #1 goal = getting students signed up to be CG leaders
  • January = getting people into CG
  • February = Discipleship/identifying future multipliers
  • March = Getting CG leaders for fall
Come up with Spring Plan

Based on current reality, what do we need to do?

 

Day 3 of Planning:

Leadership Retreat Plan

  • Leadership Retreat – coed, FUN, elements of content, overnight, just for leaders, Free!
Talk through each of our Critical Path Steps as it relates to the Spring
Eval Cru meeting
  • What do we want to keep doing?What do we need to change?
Break
What do days look like during Christmas Break
You’re working full time (just not on campus)
Look at schedule 9-5

What you could spend time on:

  • Vision Dinner- Table Host and Silent Auction
  • MPD
  • New Staff Development
  • Meet with students
  • Winter Conference job
  • Any Admin wrap up
  • Take your vacation time if you have not already
Pray together over Spring
Recap what we accomplished this week
Sharing as a team about what each of us are doing over Christmas

Stuff You Can Use in Planning

By

Our job as leaders is to see what others don’t see- to look at the same reality that everyone experiences and be able to perceive what is really going on and what needs to happen next.

A big part of that is accomplished through concentrated days of Team Planning — where we chart our course for a new year.

In most of college ministry, that time is now.

So toward that end here is some, hopefully, very practical stuff you can use to set up your planning time:

A couple key thoughts on planning:

  • Click to read yesterday’s post on our favorite way to do planning
  • We are big fans of Buckets and Holes solutions:
    • Using what we’re good at to fix what we’re bad at
  • We’re not scrapping our methods and long term goals every year and starting from scratch.
    • Our planning is framed by a 12 year plan to accomplish the vision: “that everyone on campus would know someone who passionately follows Christ”
    • We’re committed to building a movement by reaching a progressively larger freshman class every year and reaching more pockets of campus (If you’re not real sure how to go about Movement Building on a college campus, read this article: Taking a Movement from 20 to 200 )
    • So what we ARE planning is: “what do we need to do THIS year to reach a larger freshman class and more pockets of campus?”

Good analogies for planning:

  • We spend the semester furiously climbing a ladder
  • Planning is a time to stop climbing and assess whether our ladder is leaning against the right wall, to re-evaluate where we’ve been and whether we are headed in the right direction
  • Imagine we’re on a long trek thru a dense forest
  • We spend the semester plowing thru underbrush and pushing aside branches that are hitting us in the face
  • This is an opportunity to climb to the top of the tallest tree and see where we are at — to check our surroundings, look back on progress so far, and to scout out what lies ahead
  • To figure out if we’ve even been heading in the right direction

Some good questions to help you assess your movement in different ways:

  • If you were to ask a _____, what would they say about Cru (your ministry)?
    • Greek student
    • Avg freshman in dorm
    • Intl Student
    • African American student
    • Athlete
    • Hispanic student
    • Student from another ministry
    • Administration
  • What kind of people want to come to our movement?
  • Who is most invested in our movement right now?
  • Who is NOT coming to our movement? Why?
  • What kind of people have come to Christ through our movement?
  • Who are we uniquely positioned to reach?
  • Who are the “connectors” in our movement? Who can they reach?
  • If we got kicked off campus and they brought in an entirely new team, what would the new team change or do different?
  • As you look at how staff and students spend their time every week, what needs to change for the sake of effectiveness?
  • Are we attracting natural leaders? If not, what could we do differently that might help us?

Lastly, a few great planning quotes:

“The organizations that matter are busy being run by people who figure out what to do next” — Seth Godin

 “Breakthrough results come about by a series of good decisions diligently executed and accumulated one on top of another.” – Jim Collins

 “You will see less happen in one year than you would ever think, but you will see more happen in five years than you would ever dream.” – Jim Sylvester

“Simple, clear purpose and principles give rise to complex and intelligent behavior. Complex rules and regulations give rise to simple and stupid behavior.” – Dee Hock

“You’ve got to think about the big things while you’re doing small things, so that all the small things go in the right direction.” – Alvin Toffler

“The best way to get a good idea is to get lots of ideas.” – Linus Pauling

“Chance favors the prepared mind” — Louis Pasteur

photo courtesy of  sierragoddess

Planning by Putting Everything on the Wall

By

This is the best idea I’ve ever come across for planning.

How do you take all that is going on in your movement (the good and bad) and all you hope to accomplish (with often conflicting team opinions on what we should focus on next) and make sense of it all to determine what your team needs to focus on in the fall?

A few years ago I read the book The Back of the Napkin by Dan Roam. The author described a brilliant way to take a LOT of information/issues/problems and emerge with THE best solution. We’ve found this approach to be incredibly effective and a lot of fun (something no one has ever accused PrEFACE of!).

Roam calls it the garage-sale principle:

“Regardless of how well organized all the stuff in our garage may be, laying everything out on tables in the light of day yields a completely new perspective on it all. The same is true of data: when it is packed away in individual files and records, it’s impossible to look at the big picture — but getting everything out in the open makes otherwise invisible connections visible… great ideas emerged as people really looked at everything for the first time.”

The single best way to effectively to look at a lot of data is to take everything we’ve collected and lay it out side by side, where our eyes can scan it all in a few passes.

 

So how do you set it up?

  • Gather all the information (this is actually the hardest work) — get accurate stats on EVERYTHING you can. Send out staff evals to have them evaluate the current reality of the movement (here’s two we use: 1 & 2).
  • Print out all your data and information about your current reality on sheets of paper and really big sticky notes.
  • For staff planning get a conference room and cover every inch of wall with information on the current reality of your movement.
  • You want both:
    • Qualititative analysis of your movement (pictures, descriptions)
      • We have everyone draw a picture of our movement and then share it with the team
      • “What words or phrases would you use to describe the feel of our movement?”
    • Quantitative (numbers, spreadsheets!)
      • Now, I know some of you may balk at spreadsheets — I mean we are about lives being changed not numbers. But Dan Roam sums it up well: “spreadsheets are excellent tools for spreading out a lot of data on a single sheet.”
      • And without fail, numbers are what bring the most productive ideas for change as we can quickly see where we are doing well and where we are lacking.
  • Then give everyone a few minutes just to take it all in.
  • And ask something simple like, “what do you see?”

Once you lay out all the information in front of you, you can then begin to see it with more clarity.

You begin to see:

  • patterns (“we’ve had the same number of freshmen for 4 years straight” or “we’ve seen fewer people come to Christ each year”),
  • contradicting data (“this doesn’t make sense: we did WAY more first week surveys this year but the exact same number of freshmen as always — why?”),
  • what we are doing well at
  • where there are gaping holes

Here’s some of what we put up on the wall:

  • 5 Year Goals (which is an entire page of dreams we have for 2015)
  • Priority steps from our Strategic Plan from this past year (a reminder of what we focused on)
  • Goals for the year (that we brainstormed in Aug 2011) vs. reality now
  • Year Calendar (just to refresh memories on what we did this year):
    • Fall
    • Move-in week (cookouts)
    • First week — Surveys and Dorm Studies
    • Fall Retreat
    • TWC
    • Spring
    • Leadership Retreat
    • Spring Break Trips
    • Fellowship Dinner
    • Legacy Dinner
  • Our Vision Statement — printed big on a page:
    • That everyone would know someone who passionately follows Jesus
  • The following stats are most effective if you can compare to the last few years
    • # of Community Group Leaders (going into the fall)
    • # in Community Group (broken down by guys/girls AND fish/soph/jr/sr)
    • Trusted Christ
    • Summer Project (# applied AND # going)
    • Fall Retreat #’s
    • Winter Conference #’s
    • Legacy Dinner attendance (end of year banquet)
    • Involved New Believers
    • M29 Leadership (# attending weekly Leadership meeting)
    • Cru #’s avg in the Fall
    • # at last Cru in the Spring
    • # at Cru 1st week in Fall
    • # of 1st Week Spiritual Interest Surveys
    • # in Dorm Studies (big co-ed studies we do week 1&2 in fall)
    • Freshman in CG in April
    • Intern/Stint/Staff (how many laborers raised up in each of these categories)
    • Number Men/Women Discipled (start of fall/end of spring)
    • Seniors Sent
    • Times shared gospel (broken down by: 1st 4 weeks/rest of fall/spring)

As we look at it all, we record staff’s thoughts on big stickies under three categories:

  • Holes (“wow, we did not share our faith much this spring”)
  • Sustained Growth (how do we improve on what we are already good at? — “we’ve seen a big jump in SP #’s, how do we keep momentum there?”)
  • Connections (not sure if it’s a strength or weakness — just an observation: “it seems like our studies that did really well were led by juniors”)

At the end we give our staff 3-4 minutes to write their initials next to three things they think we should dig into more (and focus on during planning).

Out of that comes our 3-4 Priority Steps for the Fall.

 

Would love to hear from you:

  • What stats do you track year to year?
  • What do you do in your planning for the fall?
  • What Evals do you use?

 

Feel free to email me if you want more details on any of this (like I can send you the spreadsheet we use to track things!): timDOTcasteelATuscmDOTorg

 

Mid Year Evals

By

As we head into the final weeks of the fall semester in college ministry, it’s a great time to step back and evaluate.

I wanted to share a few resources that have been helpful for our team as we seek to figure out, as Stephen Covey says, if we have set our ladder against the right wall.

 

 

 

 

There are three evals that we do every December with our team:

  • Evaluating the Quality of Your Discipleship
  • Ministry Evaluation
  • Personal Evaluation

I’ll link to the Ministry and Personal Eval tomorrow.

Today, here’s an overview and link to the Discipleship Eval.

Evaluating the Quality of Your Discipleship

(click here to download the Word document) 

I believe this eval was developed by Roger Hershey. This tool is invaluable in evaluating two very important things:

Are we (staff and student leaders) doing the

1) Right Things with

2) The Right People?

 

Our staff and student leaders sit down and do the first part of the eval with every student they disciple (addresses the Right Things) – the student they are discipling is evaluating them:

How would you evaluate me in the three areas of discipleship:

1. Feeding them the Word          1 2 3 4 5

2. Building a relationship with them          1 2 3 4 5

3. Training them in ministry          1 2 3 4 5

What is the best thing we did or you experienced in our discipleship together this semester?

What do you wish we could change or what could I do better?

 

The second part of the eval is for each of our staff to do on their own as they evaluate whether they are investing in the Right People.

1. Which of your disciples is presently multiplying ?

2. At the end of the year, how many potential multipliers will you be replacing yourself with?

3. Of those who are not multiplying, what are the barriers?

Lack of desire, no vision or heart for multiplication

Lack of Biblical conviction about discipleship

Just too young spiritually (need time to grow)

Unable to emotionally or socially

Does not want to (opposed to multiplication)

Lack of Lordship with their time, a relationship, etc. (unwilling to die to self)

Legitimately can’t because of time (work…)

Called to another ministry

Lack of walk with the Lord

 [As a team we talked through which of these are “deal breakers” – I’ll leave that up to you and your team to decide that!]

4. What can you do to help them overcome the barriers?

5. Are there any changes you need to make in your multiplication chain?

Students who are not following through on a commitment they made

Students who do not want to multiply or do not want to be a part of the movement

 

What Evals do you use on your team? Would love for us all to share the wealth!

 

image courtesy of kanelstrand